Plant growth regulators for timothy seed production
Application of Manipulator and Modus plant growth regulators and their mixture applied at the two to three node stage consistently reduced lodging and increased timothy seed yield in the Peace River region. Manipulator or Manipulator+Moddus applied at the two to three node were most effective in increasing seed yield and economic returns.
Timothy seed production can be constrained by lodging under high moisture and high nitrogen fertility conditions. The application of plant growth regulators (PGRs) have shown success in other cool-season grass crops as a means to reduce stem elongation and lodging, and improve yield.
A five year research study was conducted in the Peace River region of western Canada to assess the effects of PGR application on lodging, plant height, seed weight and seed yield in timothy seed crops. The research was conducted at Sunset House for five years from 2019-2023 and Whitemud for three years from 2020-2022 for a total of eight site years.
Plant growth regulator treatments compared were Modus (trinexapac-ethyl; 11.3 g/l) and Manipulator (chlormequat chloride; 620g/l). They were applied alone or in a tank-mix at the 2–3 node (BBCH 32–33) and early heading (BBCH 51–52) growth stages. These treatments were compared to an untreated control for a total of seven PGR treatments. PGR rates used were Moddus alone at 537 ml/acre, Manipulator at 1 L/acre and Moddus 250 m l/acre+Manipulator 250 ml/acre).
Tuukka timothy was grown at the Whitemud site and Comtal timothy was grown at Sunset House. Agronomic management was conducted according to the cooperating farmers’ typical practices. These fields were generally established with zero-till seeding, used fall or spring fertilizer based on soil test recommendations, and an intensive weed control program with herbicides. Nitrogen fertilizer rates ranged from 58 to 80 lbs/ac (65 to 90 kg/ha).
All PGR treatments reduced plant height at all site-years compared to the control, although in some cases the differences were insignificant. At Sunset House plant height reduction ranged from 10.7 per cent for the PGR tank-mix at both stages in 2022 to 14.5 per cent reduction for the tank-mix at the heading stage in 2019.
At Whitemud, there was no difference in plant height in 2020 with PGRs, while the tank-mix reduced plant height by more than 18 per cent at both stages in 2021, and by 20 per cent with Modus applied at the two to three node stage. All treatments reduced plant height in 2023 compared to the control except Manipulator applied at the heading stage.
Lodging was generally reduced by PGR application at both application timings and sites. Lodging ratings at maturity were generally very low, even for the untreated control. At Sunset House, the untreated control ratings ranged from a low of 1.0 (1=standing; 9=flat) in years 3 and 5, to highs of 3.0 to 3.4 in the other years of production. Generally, application of PGRs at most stages resulted in lodging scores of 1.0 with a few exceptions that were never higher than the untreated control.
Timothy lodging ratings at Whitemud was higher under the good growing conditions of 2020, with the untreated control having a rating of 5.4. Modus and Manipulator applied at the two to three node stage and Modus at the heading stage had reduced lodging ratings of 2.4 to 2.5 in 2020. Lodging was low at 1.0 for the control and all treatments in 2021. In 2023, the untreated control was rated at 2.4 while all other treatments were rated at 1.0.
Highest yield at the two to three node application stage
Average across the three years at the Whitemud location, PGR application showed a consistent increase in seed yield. Manipulator, Modus, and Manipulator+Modus applied at the two to three leaf stage had a seed yield more than 10 per cent higher compared to the untreated control. For example, Modus applied at the two to three node stage averaged 595 lbs/ac (669 kg/ha) seed yield and Manipulator averaged 587 lbs/ac (659 kg/ha) compared to the control at 530 lbs/ac (595 kg/ha).
A Sunset House, Manipulator had the statistically highest seed yield applied at the two to three node stage with a five year average yield of 482 lbs/ac (542 kg/ha). This was followed by Modus at the two to three node stage with a seed yield average of 464 lbs/ac (521 kg/ha) that was also significantly higher than the other treatments and the untreated control at 429 lbs/ac (493 kg/ha).
A cost/benefit analysis was conducted that calculated the net economic benefit over the untreated control. It took into consideration the increase in seed yield and gross returns less PGR treatment/application costs. Application/treatment cost included the PGR cost (2023) plus $8.10/ac ($20/ha) application. Manipulator cost was $27/L and Modus at $44/L. The timothy seed price was $0.91/lbs ($2.00/kg).
There was a net economic benefit when PGRs were applied at the two to three leaf stage when averaged over all site-years. The highest net economic return of $9.44/ac ($23.31/ha) was the Manipulator application at the two to three node. Next highest was the Manipulator+Modus at $7.17/ac ($17.71) and Modus at $4.65/ac ($11.48) when both were applied at the two to three node stage. Application at the heading stage resulted in economic losses ranging from -$13.24 to -$21.26/ac ($32.69 to $52.52/ha).
The researchers concluded that “the lower cost per unit of Manipulator and higher seed yield when Manipulator is applied at two to three node growth stage suggest that Manipulator applications for timothy seed production will have higher seed yield and economic return.”
This project was jointly funded by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and the Peace Region Forage Seed Association.
Bhattarai, S., Poudel, H. P., Anderson, N. P., & Yoder, C. L. (2025). Plant growth regulator effects on seed yield of timothy. Crop Science, 65, e70179. OPEN ACCESS: https://doi.org/10.1002/csc2.70179
Photo courtesy Calvin Yoder
